
According to a据 survey调查 , about 66 percent of US adults are overweight or obese?约百分之六十六的美国成年人超重或肥胖? However, only 12 percent of US adults say they have ever been told by a doctor, nurse, or other health care professional about the weight issue.然而,只有百分之十二的美国成年人表示,他们从来没有一个医生,护士,或对体重问题的其他保健专业人士说。 You may be wondering why these people were not told by doctors then.你也许会奇怪,为什么这些人不是医生说,当时。 But, wait, should a doctor be responsible to inform his patient is overweight?但是,等待,医生应负责通知他的病人是超重?
We have two camps of people here:我们有两个人在这里阵营:
Those Who Against The Idea Of Doctor Telling Patients About Overweight Issue: 那些反对的医生告诉病人企业理念超重问题:
- This is a sensitive subject, especially for people who have low self-esteem.这是一个敏感的题目,特别的人谁低自尊。 So, it is better to let someone who is very close to them to say those words, rather than doctor.因此,最好是让别人谁是非常接近他们说这句话,而不是医生。 Worse, some are embarrassed and do not want to hear about it.更糟的是,有些尴尬,不想听到它。
- A lecture or “helpful reminder” may not work.的演讲或“有益的提醒”,可能无法工作。 Just like people who smoke, some overweight people already knew about that they are overweight.就像谁吸烟的人,有些超重的人已知道他们是超重。 They are reminded of it when they go shopping for clothes or when they look at mirror or when they look at models in magazine.他们提醒它当他们去购买服装时或在照镜子,或当他们在杂志模特的。 Some even know the health implications.有些甚至不知道对健康的影响。 So, if they choose to ignore it, it is nothing else a doctor can do.所以,如果他们选择忽视它,它没有别的医生可以做。

Those Who Think That Doctor Should Point Out Obesity: 那些认为医生应该指出 , 肥胖:
- Doctors should point out anything that affects the health of their patients.医生应当指出,任何影响到病人的健康。 Most patients will take note of what doctors have said, compared with advices from family members, friends or even personal trainers.大多数患者将采取什么样的医生表示,注意到,与家人,朋友,甚至私人教练建议。 After all, doctor is someone who we look up to.毕竟,医生是谁,我们期待的人最多。
- If a doctor can inform someone who is underweight, he should do the same for people who are overweight too.如果医生可以告诉谁是体重过轻的人,他应该做的人谁也超重相同。
What Mun Thinks: 什么门认为:
- The doctor should look at the big picture and determining what the patient's lifestyle before telling the patients that they are fat.医生应该看大局,确定哪些病人的生活之前,告诉病人,让他们也高。
- A doctor should know the fine line between “informing”, “advising” and “judgmental lecturing”.医生应该知道之间的界线“通知”,“建议”和“判断的说教”。 Doctor should be tactful in how he deliver the message, but that does not mean he should beat around the bush.医生应该巧妙,他是如何传递邮件,但是,这并不意味着他应该拐弯抹角。 I do not expect the doctor will say sentence like this, “You are obese and your going to die,” and then walk away.我并不指望医生会一句是这样说,“你是肥胖和你就要死了”,然后走开。 Give advice what to do.提供意见,怎样做。 Offer help.提供帮助。 Provide emotional support.提供情感支持。
- Doctor should make it a medical issue, not a beauty or appearance issue.医生应该让一个医学问题,而不是美容或外观的问题。 By doing this, patients will find it easy to accept and listen.这样,患者会发现很容易地接受和倾听。 Also, a doctor who is in good shape tend to gain trust easily in this weight issue.另外,医生在良好的状态谁是倾向于增加体重,在这个问题上轻易信任。 I doubt that you will listen to a 300-pound doctor to tel you, “Hey, you are overweight.我怀疑,你会听到一个300磅的医生电话你,“嘿,你超重。 You better watch your diet and do more exercise.”你最好注意你的饮食和多做运动。“

What do you think, should a doctor be responsible in informing his patient about overweight?你认为,应该在医生告知他的病人超重负责?
Category: 分类: Health 健康
Email This Post 通过电子邮件发送此帖
Did you like this post?喜欢这个岗位吗? Subscribe to MunFitnessBlog.com today 今天订阅MunFitnessBlog.com . 。 It is free.它是免费的。
Related Posts 相关岗位
- Singapore Stopped Anti-Obesity Plan In Schools after 15 Years新加坡停止反肥胖学校计划在15年后
- “Shrink a Few Sizes” Message Has Backfired in New York “收缩的几个大小”消息,在纽约适得其反
- Should I Only Do Weight Training After I Lose Weight?我应该做重量训练,只有当我减肥?
- Stop Obese People From Eating In Restaurant肥胖的人停止在餐厅吃饭
Scroll down to leave a comment.向下滚动到发表评论。 I really want to know what you think.我很想知道您的想法。
Found what you were looking for?找到你要找的人? If not, try searching for it below.如果没有,尝试进行搜索,它下面。


























































Janice Boyer // 贾尼斯博耶 / / May 19, 2009 at 8:45 AM 09年5月19日在上午08时45分
I am a health care professional and overweight.我是一名专业医务人员和超重。 I think a Doctor should mention to his patient the consequences of being over weight and ask the patient if it's something they want to work on and come up with a treatment plan that the patient is part of.我认为,医生应提及他的病人的后果,并要求对重病人,如果这是他们想要的工作,并提出了治疗方案,病人的一部分了。
Sometimes the encouragement and understanding, not critisim, of a person's excess weight, from their physcian is the motivation a person needs to get on a weight loss program.有时,鼓励和谅解,而不是critisim,一个人的体重超出其physcian,是激励一个人需要获得一种减肥计划。 And like others have said, we try to please our doctors because we do look up to them.而像其他人所说的,我们试图请我们的医生,因为我们视他们。 If the doctor is critical and condesending, then that'll just make the patient stay away and not seek treatment for other medical issues which will put their health at a even higher risk.如果医生是关键和condesending,那么这将只是让患者远离,而不是寻求其他医疗问题,将提出一个更高的风险,他们的保健治疗。 I agree that someone is probably not going to listen to an overweight doctor.我同意有人可能不会听医生的超重。
alfonto // alfonto / / May 19, 2009 at 8:55 AM 09年5月19日在上午8点55分
i agree with you mun.我同意你的门。
doctor should be tactful about informing his/her patient that he/she is overweight and should also making it more on medical consequences of being overweight.医生应该委婉有关通知他/她的病人,他/她是超重,也应该让更多的人患肥胖的医疗后果。 The emotional part, I think it will sink into the patient's mind after doctor informed on what could happen if the patient let all the excess weight control his/her life.的情感而言,我认为这会到病人的心灵吸收后会发生什么,如果让所有的病人控制体重超过他/她的生活情况的医生。
of course, doctor should also one who walk the talk and should be in normal BMI rather than the one who is in the “morbidly obese” BMI.当然,医生也应该走一个谁会谈,并应在正常体重,而不是一个谁是“病态肥胖”体重指数。
Patriot Henry // 爱国者亨利 / / May 20, 2009 at 11:09 AM 二零零九年五月二十○号在日上午11:09
“What do you think, should a doctor be responsible in informing his patient about overweight?” “你认为,应该在医生告知他的病人超重负责?”
Yes, they should, but only once.是的,他们应该,但只有一次。 I personally have a tremendous amount of respect for fat people, especially VERY fat people, who are that way because they enjoy the lifestyle.我个人对胖人敬佩之情,尤其是非常肥胖的人,谁是这样,因为他们喜欢的生活方式。
And why wouldn't one listen to a fat doctor speaking about the medical consequences of being overweight?而为什么没有一个听医生对肥胖的人患肥胖的医疗后果的发言? Merely because they choose to take risks doesn't mean they don't know the dangers of those risks…and they'd be much more likely to be able to speak from first hand experience.仅仅因为他们选择了冒险并不意味着他们不知道这些风险的危险...,他们会更加容易能够说出的第一手经验。
Yin Teing 尹忒嗯 // / / May 28, 2009 at 4:31 PM 2009年5月28日在日下午04:31
I feel the doctor should notify the patient if he/she is overweight because uncontrolled weight led to a lot of future medical complications.我觉得医生应通知病人,如果他/她是因为控制体重超重,导致对未来的并发症很多。 But most doctors would just say 'you just need to lose weight' without telling the 'hows'.但是,大多数医生只想说:'你只需要告诉体重丧失,但'的'hows'。 Most patients would have know that they need to lose weight- and a doctor should also identify if the overweight is attributed to depression- for that, it's a different form of treatment alltogether.大多数患者会知道他们需要减肥和医生也应确定是否超重是由于抑郁症,为此,它是一个不同的治疗产品总数的形式。
Btw Mun, congratulations- your blog is listed as #60 in the Malaysia Top Blogs by Riceblogger Btw门,祝贺您的博客被列为我在马来西亚的热门博客60 Riceblogger http://www.riceblogger.com/top-100-malaysian-blogs/ http://www.riceblogger.com/top-100-malaysian-blogs/ . 。
Keep up the good work :)保持良好的工作:)